Can we have a satisfactory realist interpretation of quantum theory, and what principles should guide our search for one? I will advocate a middle road between operationalism and unconstrained realism, guided by a methodological principle inspired by Leibniz: scenarios that are empirically indistinguishable in principle should be represented as physically identical. This principle played a pivotal role in Einstein’s development of relativity. What follows if we take it equally seriously in quantum theory? Within the conventional framework for realism, it leads to constraints that conflict with quantum predictions, as witnessed by no-go results such as Bell’s theorem and the Kochen–Specker theorem. If we are to retain the Leibnizian principle, therefore, we must move beyond this framework to a more expansive conception of realism. I propose that the central commitment of a realist should be securing causal accounts of statistical correlations, and that quantum theory calls for a revision of our notions of causation and inference, much as relativity called for a revision of our notions of space and time. A central task of this research programme is to distinguish between the parts of the quantum formalism that describe how physical systems influence one another and those that describe what we can infer about one system by learning about another. I will conclude by outlining recent work towards “unscrambling the quantum omelet.”
On achieving realism in quantum theory
Host: John Sipe